About Conestoga

There When it Matters Most.

Conestoga Title Insurance Co. is one of the most trusted names in the title insurance industry, providing the real estate, legal and financial communities with reliable title insurance since 1973. Conestoga Title’s success comes from our emphasis on building relationships through service, experience and financial security. 

We are committed to expanding our network of talented agents while providing them sophisticated and effective tools for success.  Within the title industry, Conestoga Title is a leader in training and agency support.  Our staff is friendly, knowledgeable and readily available. We keep our agents and clients informed of current events and legislation that can affect their business through our company newsletter, The WagonLode, as well as our web site, memos and verbal communication.

The success of a title company hinges upon the ability to build relationships. Our management team is comprised of experienced professionals who have earned the respect of our title agents, clients and peers in the title insurance industry.  Our commitment to personalized, professional service is a key factor in maintaining our standards of excellence while expanding our agency network.  Conestoga Title’s management team members stay abreast of changes in the industry through seminars, classes, and involvement in various state land title associations. We are also an active member of the American Land Title Association.

Conestoga Title holds an “A Prime” rating from Demotech, Inc., designating us as a company that “possesses unsurpassed financial stability related to maintaining positive surplus as regards to policyholders, regardless of the severity of a general economic downturn or deterioration in the insurance cycle.”  Conestoga Title is a wholly owned subsidiary of Donegal Mutual Insurance Co., a mutual property and casualty insurance carrier.